1971 again a quick scan of who is still speaking

1971  again  a quick scan of who is still speaking
View on original source
Category: Blend
Share
Archive
Like
. The writer is a public health and gender expert The backyard is where we look last. How many of us are genuinely concerned about human rights violations there, those lasting decades, involving people whose predicament complicates our national narratives? I have long asked this about the abandoned Pakistanis of 1971, also called stranded, most of them Biharis, who still "live" in ghettos in Bangladesh. Whataboutism is distasteful, yet every writer's freedom to choose subject, perspective and silences deserves respect. Nobody's scholarship or right to a platform is in question. But why does one part of this history command sustained attention while the fate of Bihari patriots, and of generations devastated after 1971, remains peripheral? Respecting a writer's choices should not require us to accept collective amnesia. Why do we so rarely hear Pakistan's intellectual and literary circles speak about the human rights of Pakistanis abandoned in Bangladesh, many living in deeply inhumane conditions Solidarity with the mazloomeen, the oppressed, of Bucha, Gaza or elsewhere is right, and selective morality must be challenged. This is not about competing tragedies, but universal rights must also reach those closer to home. In the first week of November 2026, I conducted a rapid online archive scan of opinion articles published in The Express Tribune between 1 October 2025 and 31 October 2026. It was a quick scan, not a systematic audit. Using the keywords 1971, Bangladesh, East Pakistan, Fall of Dhaka, stranded Pakistanis, Biharis, Urdu-speaking and Geneva Camp, in headlines or article text, the search yielded 21 op-eds by eight contributors (six men and two women, including myself). They address Bangladesh's political transition, diplomacy, trade, historical grievances and the legacy of 1971. The limits should be stated plainly. The scan covers a single newspaper, so it is indicative, not representative of Pakistan's wider discourse. My keywords include Bihari-specific terms, and eleven of the 21 pieces are mine, so the count is shaped by my own writing. A keyword search can also miss articles that take up the Bihari question in other words. Readers should weigh the findings accordingly. The male contributors accounted for nine pieces: Air Vice Marshal (retd) Shahzad Chaudhry (1), Maj Gen(retd) Inam ul Haq(1), Brig (retd) Dr Raashid Wali Janjua (1), Imtiaz Gul (3), Syed Mohammad Ali (1) and Dr Moonis Ahmar (2). Dr Ahmar has spoken and written about the Bihari question elsewhere, though his articles here during these 13 months focused on other aspects of Bangladesh. I list these names as data, not as criticism of anyone's choices. Among these articles, I found no headline or central focus addressing the suffering, sacrifices and slaughter of the Biharis, nor their repatriation and right to redistributive justice, by which I mean the state-led reallocation of wealth, resources, property and opportunity to those long denied them. I apologise in advance if my scan missed an empathetic reference by any of them or another contributor. The sole exception was the other woman writer, Shazia Tasneem Farooqi, whose column "Iqbal Rabbani's Blood-Stained Shirt" (16 December 2025) moved me deeply. By bringing her family's loss into the public narrative, she humanised a history too often reduced to abstractions. Over the same period, The Express Tribune graciously gave me space for eleven opinion pieces examining the Bihari question, the erasure of 1971, Bangladesh's political developments, and our broader obligations of historical and humanitarian empathy. Nine by the men, one by Farooqi and eleven by me make the 21. A twelfth piece of mine, "America at 250: Love, Doubt, and the Debts We Haven't Paid", explored unpaid historical debts in a wider context and also addressed 1971 and the stranded Biharis. I have kept it outside the count of 21. Political transition, the military history of 1971 and diplomatic rapprochement between Islamabad and Dhaka are important subjects in their own right. But no discussion of Bangladesh is complete without 1971, and no account of 1971 is complete without the devastation it brought to my community. Where, within these conversations, are the people who remain stranded? My separate independent research on television, "Do Pakistani Television Channels' Current Affairs Talk About the Abandoned Pakistanis of 1971? A Rapid Mapping of Broadcast Journalism (2020 to 16 December 2025)", is available on my websites. It found sustained, agenda-setting engagement difficult to identify across the channels examined. Where the issue did appear, it was a fleeting reference, charity appeal or incidental mention rather than structured inquiry. The periods and methods differ, but the question is the same: what place does this issue hold in our public discourse? Silence in the media matters because it leaves real lives unresolved. Legal recognition has not ended the problem. Bangladesh's 2008 High Court ruling on citizenship did not reach everyone in the so-called camps, and even those recognised remain unequal in practice, many still living in what are, in reality, ghettos. The Bihari question is about more than repatriation, citizenship or bilateral relations. It concerns historical responsibility, human dignity and generations left on the margins of political priorities. That responsibility belongs to writers and broadcasters, and also to the state. These people need recognition, rights, security and a durable political solution, not periodic reminders that they exist. Do we defend human rights as a principle, or only for comfortable stories? Fifty-five years on, generations have been born in those ghettos, and Pakistan rarely says their names. If we can revisit 1971, we can ask what became of those left behind. Please look again, human rights community, academics, historians, journalists, civil society, think tanks and strategic experts. Pakistan must also counter anti-state literature on 1971 built on unverified or disputed accusations, through dedicated desks and think tanks that respond with documented, evidence-based scholarship. A stable state can afford introspection. Those who stood with Pakistan's unity deserve its care. Begin with a parliamentary hearing and a clear Foreign Office position. Stability is measured by the dignity we give our own. Pakistan, please, open your heart.

(0)Comments

 

A note on cookies

Newshunt uses essential cookies to keep you signed in and to remember your language and country, so the site works the way you expect. With your permission, we'd also like to use analytics cookies to understand how people use Newshunt and improve it over time.

Accepting only affects analytics. To learn more, view our Privacy Policy or Terms & Conditions.