.
The writer is a lawyer, author and literary critic
Every few years, when revenue disappoints, the FBR discovers that the fault lies in its organogram. The latest is reversal of the 2009 integration of sales tax and income tax administration. A dedicated Member for sales tax and federal excise duty will report to the FBR Chairman.
Separate sales tax zones headed by commissioners will appear within each chief commissioner's jurisdiction, beginning with the Large Taxpayer Offices on December 1, 2026. The stated reason is a sales tax gap of Rs3.4 trillion, against Rs2 trillion for income tax.
Examine the officials' own evidence, however, and the case collapses. Around 90 per cent of sales tax comes from just 15,000 taxpayers. Of 313,000 persons registered in early 2024, only 190,000 filed returns, many declaring no taxable transactions. That is not a failure of integration. It is a failure to police a register, to ask why registered persons file nothing, year after year, without consequence.
More revealing still is the admission that in 12 manufacturing sectors with production monitoring, the gap fell by 12 percentage points in two years. In seven unmonitored sectors it rose by nine. The officers were the same and the structure was the same. What differed was a tool. If monitoring works within an integrated administration, why must the hierarchy be demolished before the tool is extended?
The other justifications are equally self-incriminating. Officers, we are told, met their combined targets by chasing income tax. That is a confession about target-setting and appraisal, curable by assigning and auditing separate targets.
A Karachi proficiency test found officers weaker in sales tax, which is a failure of training and posting, not of architecture. Officials also concede that the common Pakistan Revenue Automated Limited (PRAL) system has weakened the original rationale for integration. It does the opposite: a common digital platform is precisely what makes a single view of the taxpayer cheap.
The two taxes are two lenses on one transaction. The same sale appears in output tax, turnover and business income. Split the field offices and the same businessman will meet two commissioners, receive two sets of notices and produce the same records twice. The burden falls on the visible, compliant few who already pay. The IMF's 2010 toolkit on revenue authorities warned of exactly this duplication: multiple audits and disconnected recovery.
Nor was integration tried and found wanting. The World Bank's 2019 appraisal of the Pakistan Raises Revenue project attributed the shortcomings of the earlier reform to unsupportive tax policy, wavering commitment, poor information and communication technology (ICT) planning, frequent leadership changes, inadequate training and partial reversal of reorganisation. A reform half-implemented and repeatedly interrupted is no experiment, and its disappointing results are no verdict on its design.
What no new zone can touch is policy. The IMF recorded in 2016 that General Sales Tax (GST) exemptions in Pakistan rose from 0.1 per cent of GDP in 2012 to 0.8 per cent in 2015. A commissioner, however energetic, cannot collect what the law has forgone. Nor does a new Member address refunds withheld to flatter collections, or the protection enjoyed by powerful sectors beyond the reach of any officer.
Specialisation is welcome. Value Added Tax (VAT) needs experts in invoice chains, credits and fraud. But a specialist risk team can sit inside shared administration, with common registration, common data and coordinated audits. The honest questions are who remains outside the net, which concessions survive and why, and whether the gap is measured by a method anyone can verify. Until these are answered, Rs3.4 trillion is a slogan, not a diagnosis.
Reform that leaves exemptions, refunds, incentives and political protection untouched is merely a change of letterhead. Moving files from one room to another is easy. That is precisely why it is so often attempted.
(0)Comments