Judge's AI Error-Laden Ruling Faces Appellate Scrutiny. Are There Lessons for Lawyers?

'The cure for AI hallucinations is human verification," stated attorney Crawford Appleby. "So, no matter whether it's a solo practitioner, a big firm, the department of justice or the court itself, every statement of fact and law needs to be verified by a person. Otherwise, we will continue to see AI misuse at every level of the legal system.' Font Size Much of the conversation around artificial intelligence and the courts has focused on hallucinations in lawyers' briefs and ensuing sanctions. A Subscription is Required to Access this Content. Learn more Already a subscriber? Log in here Questions? Contact us at [email protected] | 1-855-808-4530 (Americas) | 44(0) 800 098 386009 (UK & Europe) Font Size Page printed from: NOT FOR REPRINT © 2026 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing. Continue Reading Who's on the Case? Musicians Say Suno AI Copied Their Personas, Not Their Songs Jason Isbell and other musicians are testing a new legal front against AI music generator Suno, arguing that the company misused artists' identities and voiceprints, not just copyrighted songs, to create soundalike music, descriptions and artwork. Why Winston Taylor Is Betting on Miami In this week's Legal Speak episode, Winston Taylor Miami Managing Partner Gustavo J. Membiela about the Chicago-funded firm's growth since entering the Miami market in 2022. The Measuring Device and the Machine As major firms grant billable-hour credit for AI training—rewarding lawyers for learning to eliminate hours rather than generate them—artificial intelligence threatens to sever the century-old connection between time spent and value delivered, potentially pulling apart the measuring device and the machine. The AI Evidence Problem As AI becomes embedded in the ways evidence is generated, enhanced, analyzed and authenticated, the fight will be about the foundation. It will be about reliability, transparency, bias, and the ability to challenge what the machine did. 'Serious Matter': 5th Circuit Weighs Reassignment After Judge Used AI to Draft Ruling U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate issued the temporary restraining order "on the basis of names that didn't even exist and statements that didn't even exist," said Fifth Circuit Judge Jerry Smith. "Are you saying that we can be confident that that didn't infect his ultimate reasoning?' Featured Legal Experts Edward H. Rippey Ranked in Artificial Intelligence & 1 other report Washington, District of Columbia